Moon Sighting to Moon Fighting

By Dr. Aslam Abdullah, TMO Editor-in-Chief

c24Some time ago when the Sultan of Turkey decided to introduce electricity in the Mosque of the Prophet (s), the religious scholars and leaders opposed it on the grounds that something created artificially cannot occupy a sacred place. It was not different than the opposition, the scholars raised to the printing press when it was first introduced. They in fact banned the printing of the Quran and declared it haram. Then the loudspeaker was introduced and the religious scholars opposed its use in masajid, saying that the voice radiating from it is artificial. Then the television was introduced and Muslim scholars called it the daughter of Satan and then the internet also met the same fate.

On every turn of human progress, the so called Muslim religious scholars have always created major obstacles causing immense loss to people who followed them. The irony is that when the progress bulldoze them and make them irrelevant, they succumb to the changes and shamelessly accept them denying vehemently their own earlier stance. For instance, the traditional religious scholars of Islam in India were opposed to the learning of English language and they even called it an act of disobedience to Allah, yet their descendents are not only living in English speaking countries but also making appeals for funds in English language. In fact their sustenance is dependent upon their knowledge of English.

There is only one word that describes their attitude: hypocritical. Our community is led in religious matters, by and large, by those who are hypocritical in their attitudes. A hypocrite is the one who acts on the basis of self interests in matters involving people and changes his or her position accordingly.

As long as the leadership of the community is in their hands, Islam would remain a stranger for Muslims and an irrelevant faith to people in general.

They or people like them are the ones responsible for current sorry state of affairs of Muslims in the world. They are the ones who get the podium week after week and they are the ones who run our Islamic centers and masajid. In the words of the Quran, “Deaf, dumb, and blind, they will not return (to the path). (2:18)

Their attitude to change is best described in the Quran in the following verse when it says “

“When it is said to them: “Follow what Allah hath revealed:” They say: “Nay! we shall follow the ways of our fathers.” What! even though their fathers Were void of wisdom and guidance?(2:170)

Their attitude is based on their defiance of the Quran and the Uswa (example) of the Prophet (s).

They are still adamant in their refusal to acknowledge the supremacy of the Quran and the way the Prophet implemented it. Moon sighting is one such issue that has become a moon fighting issue. A few years ago, a scholar of Islam refused to lead the taraweeh prayer on the first night of Ramadan saying that according to his school of thought, moon has not been sighted and the method of calculation to determine the new month is haram (prohibited).

A simple act of determining the birth of new moon has been presented in such a complicated manner by these scholars, that the entire Muslim world has been living under its curse for ages. The purpose of moon sighting as explained by the Prophet (s) was not moon sighting itself but it was to determine the birth of new moon to begin the new month in a scientific and calculated manner according to the tools of the time of the Prophet (s). The prophet knew the Quranic verse that says clearly: “It is He Who made the sun to be a shining glory and the moon to be a light, and measured out stages for it (moon); that you might know the number of years and the calculations. (10:5) and his main objective was to ensure that unlike his tribal practices, Muslims should not fall to the trap of arbitrarily deciding the number of months or days of months.  In order to make his point clearer about the purpose of moon sighting the Prophet (s) further elaborated that if you don’t see the new moon on the 30th of the month, start the new month the following day. So simple and so pragmatic. In other words determine the beginning of month with accuracy.

In our time, Allah has given us tools in astronomical science to determine the birth and sighting of new moon. If we do not use it, we are not only denying the laws of Allah but also defying Him. And this is what is precisely happening in the Muslim world for centuries. No one is willing to take a stand on this issue because of the culture of intimidation these leaders have created. Any challenge to their position is easily turned into a challenge to God and anyone who challenges God is either ex communicated or killed. The profanity of these so called scholars has contaminated the mind of our youth who have been given a false understanding of faith.

Yet the so called protectors of Islam, i.e. scholars have turned this simple act into a major conflict on moon sighting. Now every year, thousands of hours are wasted in deciding something that can easily be calculated according to the laws of Allah and about the laws of Allah in an disciplined manner. Nothing that is happening in the physical universe is happening without his laws and knowledge. We human beings are discovering his laws according to our level of understanding. For almost 8,000 years we believed that earth was flat but we never longer now, because we have acquired the knowledge that was already in existence in the universe.

But our religious scholars say no to this knowledge and defies Allah and his laws by saying one does not need to understand these laws and use them for the purpose of improving one’s life. Unfortunately, we have given them the responsibility of raising our younger generations. Our youth have been handed over to them like sheep and the future of Islam has become tied with their status and position. Their magical spell on people is as such that despite being rational in all matters of life, people refuse to see the absurdity of these scholars in their arguments.

In our world today, the so called religious scholars are the biggest impediment in developing a simple and accurate understanding of the Quran. They are defying God by reciting his words and they claim they are the protectors of religion. The Quran describes them aptly when it says: “The similitude of those who were charged with the (obligations of the) Mosaic Law, but who subsequently failed in those (obligations), is that of a donkey which carries huge tomes (but understands them not). Evil is the similitude of people who falsify the Signs of Allah. and Allah guides not people who do wrong.”(62:5)


3 replies
  1. Iftekhar Hussain Syed
    Iftekhar Hussain Syed says:

    A very good and relevant article. In india on the eve of every Ramzan and Eid fighting about sighting started. I want this article(translated)must be circulated among Muslims by every possible means. I am forwarding this article by email.

  2. Farooq
    Farooq says:

    Dr Abdullah, regarding your comments about trandtional Ulema of India discouraging leaning English during the British Raj, do you care to site your source? The Fatwa’s are dime a dozen so this is nothing but a cheap shot against the Ulema’s on the Indian Subcontinent.

    RAJA TANWEER says:

    never shed your tears in front of a man in your relation ,he will be taking it a joke .shed your tears in front of your lord ,he will be taking it towards a solution…..