By Michael Hastings, Rolling Stone
Earlier this week, the New York Timesâ€™ Scott Shane published a bombshell piece about Lt. Colonel Daniel Davis, a 17-year Army veteran recently returned from a second tour in Afghanistan. According to the Times, the 48-year-old Davis had written an 84-page unclassified report, as well as a classified report, offering his assessment of the decade-long war. That assessment is essentially that the war has been a disaster and the militaryâ€™s top brass has not leveled with the American public about just how badly itâ€™s been going. â€œHow many more men must die in support of a mission that is not succeeding?â€ Davis boldly asks in an article summarizing his views in The Armed Forces Journal.
Davis last month submitted the unclassified report – titled â€œDereliction of Duty II: Senior Military Leaderâ€™s Loss of Integrity Wounds Afghan War Effortâ€ – for an internal Army review. Such a report could then be released to the public. However, according to U.S. military officials familiar with the situation, the Pentagon is refusing to do so. Rolling Stone has now obtained a full copy of the 84-page unclassified version, which has been making the rounds within the U.S. government, including the White House. Weâ€™ve decided to publish it in full; itâ€™s well worth reading for yourself (http://www1.rollingstone.com/extras/RS_REPORT.pdf). It is, in my estimation, one of the most significant documents published by an active-duty officer in the past ten years.
Here is the reportâ€™s damning opening lines: â€œSenior ranking U.S. military leaders have so distorted the truth when communicating with the U.S. Congress and American people in regards to conditions on the ground in Afghanistan that the truth has become unrecognizable. This deception has damaged Americaâ€™s credibility among both our allies and enemies, severely limiting our ability to reach a political solution to the war in Afghanistan.â€ Davis goes on to explain that everything in the report is â€œopen sourceâ€ – i.e., unclassified – information.
According to Davis, the classified report, which he legally submitted to Congress, is even more devastating. â€œIf the public had access to these classified reports they would see the dramatic gulf between what is often said in public by our senior leaders and what is actually true behind the scenes,â€ Davis writes. â€œIt would be illegal for me to discuss, use, or cite classified material in an open venue and thus I will not do so; I am no WikiLeaks guy Part II.â€
According to the Times story, Davis briefed four members of Congress and a dozen staff members and sent his reports to the Defense Departmentâ€™s inspector general, and of course spoke to a New York Times reporter; only after all that did he inform his chain of command what heâ€™d been up to. Evidently Davisâ€™s truth-telling campaign has rattled the Pentagon brass, prompting unnamed officials to retaliate by threatening a bogus investigation for â€œpossible security violations,â€ according to NBC News.
Although Davisâ€™s critics have tried to brush off his claims as merely the opinions of a â€œreservist,â€ – as Max Boot put it – his report is full of insight, analysis, and hard data that back up each one of his claims. He details the gross failure of training the Afghan Army, the militaryâ€™s blurring of the lines between public affairs and â€œinformation operationsâ€ (meaning, essentially, propaganda), and the Pentagonâ€™s manipulation of the U.S. media. (He expertly contrasts senior military officials public statements with the actual reality on the ground.) Davis concludes: â€œIt is my recommendation that the United States Congress – the House and Senate Armed Services Committees in particular – should conduct a bi-partisan investigation into the various charges of deception or dishonesty in this report and hold broad hearings as well,â€ he writes. â€œThese hearings need to include the very senior generals and former generals whom I refer to in this report so they can be given every chance to publicly give their version of events.â€ In other words, put the generals under oath, and then see what story they tell.
Michael Hastings is a contributing editor to Rolling Stone and author of The Operators: The Wild and Terrifying Inside Story of Americaâ€™s War in Afghanistan.